March 19, 2006
Daryl Plummer is the (only?) Gartner person that consistently makes sense to me.
From Optimize Magazine: Web Services At A Crossroads:
“Users fall into two camps. One group advocates using Web services to build complex internal systems known as enterprise service-oriented architectures (SOAs). The other seeks to use emerging Web technologies in tandem with Web services to create flexible external applications. Their divergent approaches each require different organizational skill sets.
The split began in 2003, when companies such as BEA Systems, IBM, Microsoft, and Sun Microsystems questioned whether mission-critical systems were possible with Web services as originally defined. Over the next two years, the Web took on new significance as Google’s use of advanced techniques and Web services began to get widespread notice.
When it comes to building SOAs, I can’t get over how much effort is wasted trying to force Web services to deliver enterprise-level capabilities they were never intended to handle. For example, managers at a well-known airline once asked me how to make their Web services provide an enterprise-level distributed-transaction environment, given the shortcomings of the Web services standards. ‘Did you consider using a real distributed transaction environment instead of Web services?’ I asked. The looks on their faces indicated they hadn’t.”
Tim Bray has some pointed comments on Mr Plummer’s article. While I think they are reasonable, I think Mr Plummer’s paints the big picture well.
Finally, it reminds me of something Don Box said about supporting REST and WS-*.
Leave a Comment » |
Uncategorized |
Permalink
Posted by tjor
March 4, 2006
A post or two ago I wrote about “considerations.” Well, after considering it, I think I’m wrong and what I meant to say was “concerns.” Concerns is around AOP. My original note was something I wrote on a piece of paper during a presentation by a VP in HP, and he was saying considerations.
But I digress. Considerations…Concerns…either way there is a buzzword brewing here once we get past Web 2.0.
Leave a Comment » |
Uncategorized |
Permalink
Posted by tjor